COMMENT: In the world of football management, there’s a fine line between reasons and excuses. And right now, Erik ten Hag is finding himself walking that tightrope. As loyal followers of this column will know, we’ve been in Ten Hag’s corner at Manchester United. And despite recent setbacks, we still believe he deserves the chance to prove himself in the final year of his contract.
But let’s be clear, there are reasons and then there are excuses. The aftermath of Monday night’s disastrous performance at Crystal Palace sounded more like the latter. Yes, Ten Hag had to deal with a makeshift defense, a bench full of youngsters, and players out of position. But even with the club’s injury crisis, there is no excuse for the collapse we witnessed. United were completely outplayed by a good Palace team, but they should not have been four goals better than us.
This is where Ten Hag needs to be careful. Injuries and constant changes can explain the team’s inconsistency and lack of fluidity. However, they cannot excuse such a humiliating defeat. This is what Ten Hag was hired for – to find solutions and win games, even in difficult circumstances. Unfortunately, that didn’t happen on Monday night, and regardless of the injury list, conceding four goals is unacceptable.
Should this result determine Ten Hag’s fate? Absolutely not. It seems that the higher-ups at United are starting to recognize the challenges he has faced this season. Last season’s success should not be ignored, and there are valid reasons for the current problems. But patience can only last for so long.
“I did my job and in the first year I would say it was a good formation,” said Ten Hag ahead of Sunday’s clash with Arsenal. “We played to our levels, maybe we over-performed. In this one we haven’t and I know why, but we are still in an FA Cup final and that is a great achievement.”
While doubts still linger, Ten Hag has found some allies in his corner. The club’s new technical director, Jason Wilcox, and Sir Ian Brailsford are starting to understand the difficult hand Ten Hag has been dealt. Even Gary Neville, a United legend, believes Ten Hag should be given another year. Tribalfootball.com spoke to Gary Pallister and Rene Meulensteen, both of whom acknowledged the impact of injuries on the team.
Pallister shared his own experience, highlighting the importance of a stable and consistent back four. United have lacked that all season, which has affected their defensive record. Those who have been in Ten Hag’s shoes understand the challenges he faces, and they are willing to give him some leeway.
The majority connected to the club want to see stability and continuity. As Meulensteen said, “Every successful club is built on two main pillars; stability and continuity.” This is what Ratcliffe is seeking, which explains the rumors of Steve McClaren being offered a longer deal. United’s interest in Gary O’Neil also aligns with their desire for long-term stability.
Ten Hag has the opportunity to provide that stability as manager. However, it will only work if he delivers the right results. Injuries can be a reason, but they cannot be an excuse. Ten Hag cannot afford another disastrous night like Monday in South London. The pressure is on, but if he can turn things around, he may just earn that longer deal and prove himself worthy of the United job.
